10 Best Italian restaurants in New York City, NY

Updated November 2026 · Ranked by customer ratings and number of reviews on Search Acharya.

  1. OLIO E PIÙ

    No reviews yet Greenwich Village Open until 12 am

    Italian restaurant in Greenwich Village offering all-day dining and extended evening hours. The restaurant serves Italian dishes and provides options for lunch, dinner, takeout and social dining.

  2. L’Osteria

    No reviews yet Upper East Side Closed, opens 12 pm

    Italian restaurant on the Upper East Side serving lunch and dinner throughout the week. The restaurant offers Italian dishes in a neighborhood setting suitable for casual meals, business dining and r…

  3. Canto West Village

    No reviews yet West Village Closed, opens 11 am

    Italian restaurant in the West Village offering afternoon and evening dining with extended hours Thursday through Saturday. The restaurant provides Italian-inspired dishes for dinner and weekend dayt…

  4. Osteria Nonnino

    No reviews yet West Village Closed, opens 12 pm

    Italian restaurant in the West Village offering evening Italian dining and weekend lunch service. The menu focuses on Italian-style dishes in a neighborhood restaurant environment.

  5. La Pecora Bianca SoHo

    No reviews yet SoHo Open until 10:30 pm

    Italian restaurant in SoHo serving Italian-inspired dishes including pasta along with lunch, dinner and weekend daytime dining. The restaurant is suitable for casual meals, brunch-style dining and re…

  6. Sicily Osteria

    No reviews yet Times Square Closed, opens 12 pm

    Sicilian and Italian restaurant near Times Square offering lunch and dinner service throughout the week. The restaurant features Italian-inspired dishes and an evening dining environment suitable for…

  7. Water & Wheat Upper East

    No reviews yet Upper East Side Closed, opens 11:30 am

    Italian restaurant on the Upper East Side offering lunch and dinner every day. The restaurant provides Italian-style dishes in a neighborhood dining environment suitable for casual meals and evening…

  8. Osteria La Baia

    No reviews yet Midtown Manhattan Open until 12 am

    Italian restaurant in Midtown Manhattan offering Italian dishes throughout the day. The restaurant provides breakfast and full-service dining with pasta and Italian-inspired menu options for lunch an…

  9. La Lanterna di Vittorio

    No reviews yet Greenwich Village Open until 2 am

    Italian restaurant in Greenwich Village offering extended daily dining hours. The restaurant provides Italian cuisine suitable for lunch, dinner and late-night dining in a neighborhood setting.

  10. Osteria Carlina West Village

    No reviews yet West Village Closed, opens 4:30 pm

    Northern Italian restaurant in the West Village offering dinner service throughout the week. The restaurant focuses on Italian cuisine and provides an evening dining environment suitable for local di…

How we rank

We look at every italian restaurant listed in New York City on Search Acharya and rank them by their average rating, weighted by how many customers left a review – so a business with many good reviews ranks above one with a single perfect score. Paid and featured listings get no advantage on this page. The list updates automatically as new reviews come in.

Used one of these businesses? Leave a review to help your neighbours.

Grow Your Business with Search Acharya

Get more customers, increase your reach and boost your business online.

Register Your Business Now