3 Best Mexican restaurants in New York City, NY

Updated November 2026 · Ranked by customer ratings and number of reviews on Search Acharya.

  1. Toro Loco

    No reviews yet Financial District Closed, opens 11:30 am

    Mexican restaurant in Lower Manhattan serving lunch and dinner throughout the week. The restaurant offers Mexican-inspired dishes and an evening-friendly setting for groups and casual dining.

  2. Mezcali

    No reviews yet Financial District Open until 2 am

    Mexican restaurant in Lower Manhattan serving lunch and dinner with extended late-night hours during the week. The restaurant provides a casual social setting for Mexican food, drinks and groups.

  3. Amor Loco

    No reviews yet Times Square Closed, opens 11:30 am

    Mexican restaurant near Times Square offering lunch and dinner service throughout the week. The restaurant provides Mexican-inspired dishes and a lively dining setting suitable for groups and evening…

How we rank

We look at every mexican restaurant listed in New York City on Search Acharya and rank them by their average rating, weighted by how many customers left a review – so a business with many good reviews ranks above one with a single perfect score. Paid and featured listings get no advantage on this page. The list updates automatically as new reviews come in.

Used one of these businesses? Leave a review to help your neighbours.

Grow Your Business with Search Acharya

Get more customers, increase your reach and boost your business online.

Register Your Business Now